The Optimist’s Case For Bungie’s ‘Marathon’

Ever because the debut of Marathon’s gameplay this previous weekend, “discourse” has been swirling about how the sport appears to be like, and it’s a bit burying your head within the sand to say most chatter wasn’t majority destructive.

This ranges from very pointless “the clones are woke” debates to precise criticism of the way it appears to play, and the way it would possibly carry out within the bigger aggressive PvP business at the next value level and a considerably content-bare launch. I’ve participated in that myself quite a bit.

So, can I look on the brilliant facet right this moment? I’ll attempt to make an optimist’s case for Marathon right here, and even when all of this doesn’t pan out, if anybody can break right into a crowded market, it’s Bungie.

It’s Bungie – That’s my first level right here. This can be a studio that made Halo and Future, that means they haven’t labored on a failed franchise in 25 years. They’ve a few of the best-feeling gunplay within the enterprise, and I do know you’re about to say “nearly all of the previous Bungie persons are gone,” however properly, Bungie remains to be pumping out great-feeling weapons and sandbox adjustments in Future to today, so that’s clearly nonetheless of their ability set. And is a sport that blends the massively in style Apex legends with the massively in style Tarkov and Future-feeling gunplay actually that unhealthy? I’d argue it’s prone to be the other.

AAA, Extra Accessible Extraction Capturing – There simply isn’t a wide-ranging extraction shooter available on the market at this scale. Particularly one that can take goal on the console market in a manner few have tried up to now. We’re all saying “properly I don’t need to play an extraction shooter,” however we’re largely basing that on the hardcore ones like Tarkov that are just about inaccessible on objective. Bungie may change minds about that, and this concept could also be higher than merely doing one other area shooter or battle royale in the long run, even when elements of it might really feel considerably by-product.

Devoted Servers, Much less Dishonest – Bungie is lastly pulling the set off on devoted servers for a PvP sport, one thing followers at all times need on this style. And if there’s one benefit to a mid-range value level for the sport it’s that it’s going to lower down on dishonest on the very least, whether or not it makes the sport a tougher promote or not.

Sony Assist – Regardless of how Marathon launches, I don’t suppose Sony has it in them to tug the plug tremendous early on one other sport like this, not after Harmony. Sinking extra assets into Marathon growth to make it higher and higher in time might be extra price it than confirming one thing as one more large failure, cementing the concept that they really don’t know what they’re doing on this style. Marathon will see continued funding, I’m nearly positive of it.

A Distinctive Aesthetic that Might Nonetheless Enhance – Harmony by no means regarded good. Not as soon as. It was clearly banking on a quasi-Guardians of the Galaxy vibe, plus 70s-inspired character designs. It simply regarded horrible. You merely can’t say that with Marathon with a straight face, no less than when it comes to total design and the vibe this whole aesthetic has. There have been some complaints about how that interprets into onscreen play, however I believe that will change as soon as persons are taking part in in 4K, and Bungie has reminded us that a few of this footage is older builds in pre-alpha, so there’s nonetheless room for extra enchancment.

The Fourth Map – Bungie and a few participant testers have been consistently hyping up some fourth map that’s not launching with the sport, however is meant to be the distinctive twist on the extraction idea in a manner we haven’t seen earlier than. Why on earth we’re not seeing this now, I don’t know, nor why the sport isn’t ready to launch with it, but when this delivers, that could possibly be superb information.

After all, the other of all of this could possibly be true:

• Individuals consider Bungie’s time has come and gone and don’t tune in
• Individuals simply don’t need to play extraction shooters no matter accessibility, or it simply isn’t accessible.
• The price of the sport as an alternative of being free-to-play isn’t price marginally much less dishonest.
• Sony remains to be skittish and doesn’t need to throw good cash after unhealthy if the sport doesn’t land properly
• The sport merely doesn’t look nice in-engine when performed and may’t enhance a lot previous that.
• The fourth map launches too late for individuals to care, and you may’t promote individuals on one thing that isn’t even right here but.

It relies upon what you need to select to consider. In the long run, I’ve extra considerations than I’ve a glass overflowing with optimism, however we simply can’t dictate what’s going to or is not going to occur based mostly on a single showcase. The largest exams would be the vibes that come out of the closed alpha, however extra importantly the open beta. If it doesn’t impress there, that’s when the intense issues start. But when it does? Everybody could begin shifting their view the opposite route.

Comply with me on Twitter, YouTube, and Bluesky

Decide up my sci-fi novels the Herokiller series and The Earthborn Trilogy.